This article critically examines how readers engage with two novels by William Faulkner (Light in August and The Wild Palms). It explores the idea of reading as an act that balances the predictable (what readers expect based on narrative structures and prior information) with the unpredictable (elements of surprise, irony, and narrative indeterminacy). The author argues that Faulkner’s narratives structure the reading experience so that the reader is constantly negotiating between anticipating events (predictability) and confronting unexpected developments (unpredictability). This interplay is central to understanding character motivations, thematic depth, and Faulkner’s literary techniques.